Caribbean Tourism Needs Leaders, Not Just Visitors
The Caribbean has never been short of visitors. What it has sometimes lacked is the continuity to turn those visitors into lasting prosperity. The numbers are good. Last year the region recorded a 2.5 per cent increase in international stay-over arrivals, to an estimated 35 million visits. Cruise visits rose too, up 5.2% to roughly 35.5 million. Yet the mood among the people who study the industry is less celebratory than the headlines suggest. A growing number of them are asking a harder question than “how many?” They want to know who is steering the ship, and whether anyone will still be at the wheel after the next election.
A Region Growing Slowly, and Unevenly
The latest figures add some friction to the story. At the Caribbean Tourism Organization’s State of the Tourism Industry Conference in Guyana, officials reported that stayover arrivals rose just 1.9 per cent in the first half of 2026, even as cruise passenger visits jumped 11 per cent to a record 21.7 million. That is roughly 18.9 million stayover visitors, against 18.6 million a year earlier. The global backdrop is soft as well. UN Tourism puts worldwide international arrivals up only 0.4 per cent in the same period.
Look closer and the picture fragments. Arrivals from South America climbed 19.5 per cent to about 1.19 million, lifting that market’s share of regional arrivals to 6.3 per cent. Individual destinations are moving at very different speeds. St. Vincent and the Grenadines, for example, reported an 8.4 per cent rise in visitor arrivals between January and August.
For travelers, this matters more than it might seem. A region that grows through cruise volume rather than overnight stays behaves differently on the ground. Cruise passengers spend hours ashore, not nights, and the economic benefit per visitor is generally smaller. Meanwhile, overnight guests are the ones who fill small guesthouses, restaurants and tour operators.
The Leadership Question
Dr. Sherma Roberts has spent decades in the middle of this debate. She is a Senior Lecturer in Tourism and Hospitality Management at UWI’s Cave Hill campus in Barbados. She has served as Chair of the Tobago Tourism Agency and Deputy Chair of the Barbados Tourism Product Authority, and she helped shape the Barbados Tourism White Paper for 2012 to 2021. She is, in other words, both a scholar of tourism governance and someone who has sat in the room where it happens.
Her diagnosis at the CTO’s sustainability conference in Belize was pointed. The most damaging pattern, she argued, is the political cycle. Policies are drafted, funded and sometimes launched, then quietly abandoned when a new government arrives. She urged young professionals to push for continuity, and to form their own consultancy groups instead of defaulting to outside consultants.
It is a sharp observation, and a familiar one across small island states, where ministerial turnover can reset priorities every few years. A traveler never sees this directly. What they notice are the symptoms: a heritage site left half-restored, a marketing campaign that vanishes after one season, a sustainability pledge that fades once its champion moves on. Her colleague Dr. Mechelle Best, Dean of the College of Health and Human Development at California State University, Northridge, put the test plainly. Change counts as meaningful only if it survives the person who started it.
Dependence Versus Over-Dependence
Roberts made a distinction that deserves more attention than it usually gets. Dependence on tourism is not the problem, she said. Over-dependence is. In a region where the sector is a pillar of national economies, and one of the most tourism-reliant regions in the world, that is not a call to abandon the industry. It is a call to run it differently.
Best echoed the point from another angle. The region may not be able to reduce its reliance on tourism, she suggested, but it can make the sector more resilient and capture more of its benefits.
This is where regional institutions have started to move. At Caribbean Week in New York last June, the CTO launched a Tourism Supply Side Committee, an initiative aimed at strengthening regional linkages, increasing economic retention and building a more integrated and resilient Caribbean tourism economy. One report describes the effort as aiming to build regional supply chains, scale local producers and potentially develop Caribbean-owned digital marketing platforms. The idea echoes what Roberts described when she spoke about local ownership and linkages. Picture a hotel stocking locally made soaps and sourcing its produce from nearby farms, rather than importing both.
It is a simple idea with a difficult execution. Economic leakage, the share of tourist spending that flows back out of an island through imports and foreign ownership, has dogged the industry for decades (general knowledge). A committee will not fix it alone. But the fact that the region’s own tourism body has made retention a stated priority is a meaningful shift in tone, from counting arrivals to counting value.
Who Tells the Story?
Roberts also challenged how the region presents itself. The Caribbean is too often sold as paradise, she argued, when it is better understood as a place of enjoyment, pleasure and learning. In her view the focus should fall on people and immersive experiences, not only the beach.
She was candid about the commercial reality too. Culture has to create value, she said, so some commodification is unavoidable. But the industry should distinguish between what it shares and what it keeps. She cautioned against romanticizing poverty: a woman cooking over a coal pot may read as authentic to a visitor, yet the work involves long hours and health risks. It is a useful test for any operator designing a “local experience.”
For travelers, this is the most practical part of the conversation. The best trips in the region tend to be those where the host, rather than the brochure, is in charge of the narrative. If you are choosing between a polished resort package and a community-run experience that pays residents fairly, the latter often tells you more about the place.
Dr. Acolla Lewis-Cameron, Dean of the Faculty of Social Sciences at UWI’s St. Augustine campus, framed the matter as confidence. She described a lingering mentality that foreign is always better, and called on the region to trust what it can offer, change and manage itself.
Leadership Beyond the Boardroom
There was a quieter thread in the Belize discussions that deserves airtime. Best spoke about the persistence of sexism in tourism spaces, where expertise is sometimes assumed to belong to men whatever the credentials. She also noted a younger generation of entrepreneurs, many using social media to build their own routes into the industry, who are reshaping who participates.
Lewis-Cameron added that these digitally fluent newcomers need real opportunities, not token ones, and should not be treated as inexperienced. She also pointed to a long gap between academia and industry, arguing that researchers can supply frameworks policymakers can use.
Roberts offered a small but telling example of the pipeline working. She taught Narendra Ramgulam, who is now Deputy Director of Sustainable Tourism at the CTO. Leadership, in that sense, is something built slowly, in classrooms and mentoring, long before anyone is appointed to a board.
There are encouraging signs at the top as well. Antigua and Barbuda has taken over the CTO chair, with Colin James, CEO of the Antigua and Barbuda Tourism Authority, succeeding Andrea Franklin of Barbados Tourism Marketing Inc. The handover was orderly, and the CTO’s Reimagine Plan carries forward. The region’s tourism bodies have also shown they can cooperate on practical matters. At February’s Air Connectivity Summit in Bermuda, a clear theme was the need for regional cooperation rather than destinations competing independently for the same routes.
The Caribbean’s competitors are not standing still. Destinations around the world are chasing the same high-spending, experience-seeking traveler, and many have deeper marketing budgets. The Caribbean’s advantage is difficult to copy: distinct cultures, living food traditions and a regional identity that is richer than any single beach.
But advantage only compounds when it is managed over time. The scholars who gathered in Belize were not predicting decline. They were making a narrower argument: that growth without continuity, ownership and honest storytelling will leave the region busier but not necessarily better off.
For the traveler, the takeaway is practical. Stay longer where you can. Eat where the ingredients are grown nearby. Ask who owns the place you are sleeping in. For the industry, the test will be quieter and harder: whether the Supply Side Committee, the Reimagine Plan and the new generation of Caribbean-trained leaders are still pursuing the same goals when the next government, and the next hurricane season, arrive.
Photo credit: Christian Lendl

