Grenada’s Spice Farmers Replant After Hurricane Loss

The scent reaches you before the town of Gouyave does, a warm, resinous sweetness drifting from open-air drying sheds where nutmeg husks split to reveal the lacy red mace wrapped around the seed inside. Grenada has been known as the Isle of Spice since British and French colonizers first planted nutmeg here in the 1840s, and for over a century the industry made this small island one of the world’s top two or three producers, its economy and self-image bound up in a fruit that most of the world has never seen whole.

Then, in 2004, Hurricane Ivan tore through Grenada and flattened an estimated 90 percent of its nutmeg trees. Hurricane Emily followed the next year, finishing off much of what Ivan had spared. Nutmeg trees take roughly seven to ten years to bear fruit reliably, meaning an entire generation of Grenadian farmers effectively lost their livelihood overnight and faced a decade-long wait before recovery could even begin to show results.

At the Grenada Cooperative Nutmeg Association’s processing station in Gouyave, a squat concrete building that has operated in some form since 1947, station manager Cheryl Baptiste walks me through drying racks stacked three stories high, where nutmeg seeds cure slowly over six to eight weeks until they rattle audibly inside their shells, the traditional test for readiness. “Before Ivan, this building was full, floor to ceiling,” she says, gesturing at racks that are perhaps two-thirds occupied today, over two decades after the storm. “We are still not back to where we were.”

The recovery has been slower and more complicated than simple replanting might suggest. Farmers who lost mature trees had to decide whether to gamble years of labor and land on a crop that would not generate income for the better part of a decade, during a period when many households needed immediate income simply to rebuild homes and replace lost infrastructure. Many switched partially or fully to faster-yielding crops — cocoa, which fruits within three to four years, or fruits and vegetables for local markets — hedging against another storm wiping out a long-term investment before it ever paid off.

Kimlan Frank, a farmer in the hills above Gouyave whose family has grown nutmeg for three generations, shows me a plot where roughly half the trees are young, feathery specimens planted within the last decade, interspersed with the thicker, taller survivors from before Ivan. He walks with a particular caution around the older trees, checking branches for disease and pruning selectively, aware that each surviving tree represents years of accumulated growth that cannot simply be replaced by planting a new sapling. “A young tree gives you maybe two pounds of nutmeg a year,” he explains, cracking open a ripe fruit to show the mace inside, its color a startling scarlet against the pale nutmeg shell. “An old tree, twenty years old, can give sixty, seventy pounds. You cannot rush that.”

The mace itself, once separated from the seed and flattened, dried, and graded, commands a higher price per pound than the nutmeg it surrounds — a fact that surprises most visitors, who assume nutmeg is the primary product and mace a byproduct rather than a distinct and valuable spice in its own right. Kimlan sells both through the cooperative, which pools output from small farmers across the island and handles export logistics that would be impossible for an individual grower to manage alone.

Walking through Gouyave’s Friday night fish fry, a weekly street event where the town’s fishing catch is grilled and fried at stalls lining the main road, I find nutmeg worked into unexpected corners of the local food culture — grated into rum punches at makeshift bars, folded into ice cream sold from a cooler by a woman who has run the same stand for over a decade, sprinkled over stewed fruit desserts served alongside grilled mahi-mahi and jack fish. It is treated here not as an exotic spice reserved for baking, but as an everyday seasoning as unremarkable and essential as salt.

At Belmont Estate, an old plantation-turned-agritourism operation in the island’s northeast, I meet Shadel Nyack Compton, whose family has run the property for decades and who has worked to diversify its output beyond raw nutmeg export into value-added products — nutmeg jelly made from the fruit’s outer flesh (usually discarded entirely in traditional processing), nutmeg-infused syrups, and small-batch chocolate made from cocoa grown on the same estate. It is, she explains, a hedge against the volatility of raw commodity prices and another storm season, an attempt to extract more value from every part of the tree and fruit rather than relying solely on the seed itself.

Standing in Belmont’s drying shed at dusk, watching workers turn nutmeg seeds by hand to ensure even curing, Shadel reflects on what the recovery has actually meant on the ground — not a triumphant return to pre-Ivan production levels, which by most estimates remains years away if it happens at all, but a slower, more deliberate rebuilding that has forced farmers to diversify, to hedge, to think differently about resilience than their parents and grandparents did. Grenada may never again produce nutmeg at the volumes it did in the 1990s. What it has produced instead, out of necessity, is a generation of farmers more attuned to the risks of relying on a single crop and a single storm-vulnerable model, however painful that education has been.

Driving away from Gouyave as the drying sheds close for the evening, the scent of curing nutmeg still clinging to my clothes, it is hard not to read the island’s spice industry as a quiet parable about patience under climate pressure — an industry rebuilding itself tree by tree, a decade at a time, with no guarantee that the next storm season won’t undo the work again.

More Food & Wine Articles