Hunting Crayfish in Dominica’s Ancient River Valleys

The Indian River is not actually named for the people who first inhabited this island, though it flows past the edge of what was once their territory and still carries, in its lower reaches, the cool clarity of water that has not yet been touched by the coast’s heat. It is brown with tannins in the rainy season, pale green in the dry months, and it is home to a freshwater crayfish — Macrobrachium carcinus, known locally as “crabes de rivière” — that has been part of Dominican cuisine since before European contact.

Clement Augustine, who goes by “Auntie Clem” despite being a sixty-year-old man, has been catching river crayfish in Dominica’s northern river systems since childhood. He is part of a community in the Calibishie area, on the island’s Atlantic coast, and he works the rivers in the early morning, in the hours before the light becomes strong enough to make the water opaque. Crayfish, he explains, are easier to find in the low-light conditions of dawn, when they are still active near the riverbed rather than sheltered beneath rocks.

His equipment is minimal: a mesh hand net, a headlamp for the pre-dawn hours, and a plastic bucket with a lid. He wears shorts and old canvas shoes that he doesn’t mind getting wet. He enters the river at a point where the current is slow and the bottom is visible, moving upstream with careful deliberation, disturbing the water as little as possible.

Dominica is the wettest island in the Caribbean, receiving rainfall that sustains 365 rivers — one, according to local lore, for every day of the year. This abundance of freshwater is the ecological foundation for the island’s distinct cuisine, which relies on river resources in ways that distinguish it from the fish-and-seafood cultures of its drier Caribbean neighbors. River crayfish, river crab, and freshwater shrimp all appear regularly in Dominican cooking, prepared in methods that trace back to the Kalinago people who inhabited the island before and through the colonial period.

“The Kalinago used to cook them in the shell on a fire,” Clement says, pausing at a deeper pool where the current eddies around a submerged rock. “They didn’t take them apart first. The shell kept the flavor inside.”

He locates a crayfish by the movement of its antennae, which extend from beneath the rock before the animal itself becomes visible. The net goes in at an angle, cutting off the backward escape route that is the crayfish’s primary defense. The animal retreats directly into it. Clement lifts the net in a single smooth motion, checks the size, and transfers the crayfish to his bucket.

Mature M. carcinus can reach impressive sizes — the claws of large males can span more than eight inches — but Clement targets medium specimens, which he considers better for eating and which, he notes, are more likely to have reproduced at least once. “You leave the big ones to make more. You leave the small ones to grow. You take the middle ones. That’s how you keep coming back.”

The morning’s catch, an hour’s work along three hundred meters of river, yields thirty-seven crayfish. He carries them back to a wooden structure near the riverbank where his wife, Rosalie, has a fire already built. She cooks them in two ways: some simply, in salted water with thyme and garlic, to establish the base flavor of the animal; others in a Creole stew with tomatoes, onions, scotch bonnet, and the cooking liquor from the first batch, which concentrates into a broth with the sweet-mineral intensity of good shellfish stock.

The simply cooked crayfish, eaten from the shell by hand, taste of the river with an overlay of sweetness that freshwater crustaceans have in a way that their saltwater relatives do not. The meat is denser than shrimp, the texture somewhere between lobster and langostine, the flavor clean and direct. Rosalie provides a small dish of the stew’s broth for dipping, and this takes the flavor from clean to complex, the tomato and scotch bonnet adding layers that the crayfish’s own character can absorb without disappearing beneath them.

Eating beside the river that provided the meal, with the sound of the current in the background and the damp forest air cooling the afternoon, produces a quality of satisfaction that is partially nutritional and partially environmental. The crayfish came from this specific river, prepared by the people who know it best, eaten within sight of the water. The chain from source to table is so short as to be nearly unmediated.

Clement is already thinking about tomorrow’s spot — a section of the Melville Hall River he hasn’t worked in two weeks, where the pools were promising the last time he checked. He has been mapping these rivers in his memory for fifty years, accumulating knowledge that has no other repository.

“You have to know the river in every season,” he says, looking downstream toward where the forest thins and the first houses of the village become visible. “In dry season the pools are here. In wet season the fish move, the crayfish move. You have to move with them.”

The bucket is empty. The fire is low. Rosalie is washing the cooking pot in the shallows. The river moves past all of it with no particular interest in any of it, doing what rivers do.

More Food & Wine Articles