Anguilla Crowned Caribbean’s Safest Paradise: What Travel Industry Professionals Need to Know About This Security Success Story

Let me tell you something that’s been creating quite a buzz in Caribbean tourism circles lately—Anguilla, that relatively quiet British overseas territory just north of St. Maarten, has officially been recognized as the safest destination in the entire Caribbean region. According to the 2025 World Population Review rankings, which analyzed everything from crime statistics to political stability using Global Peace Index data, this 35-square-mile island is demonstrating exactly what security-conscious tourism development looks like when done right.

For those of us working in travel and tourism, this isn’t just another feel-good ranking to add to the promotional materials. This represents a fundamental shift in how regional destinations are being evaluated and what discerning travelers—particularly those from North American and European markets—are prioritizing when planning their getaways. The designation carries significant weight from both traveler confidence and tourism economics perspectives, especially as post-pandemic travelers continue placing safety at the very top of their vacation checklists.

What makes Anguilla’s achievement particularly noteworthy is the comprehensive nature of its safety profile. The island doesn’t just excel in one area—it demonstrates remarkably low crime rates across the board. According to the World Population Review analysis, violent and petty crimes are exceptionally rare here, creating what researchers describe as an authentic “tropical oasis” atmosphere where tourists genuinely feel secure exploring independently.

John Rose, who serves as chief risk adviser for Altour, a global travel management company, points to several distinct advantages that contribute to Anguilla’s exceptional safety record. The island’s geographical isolation and limited access points naturally reduce cross-border criminal activity that affects other Caribbean destinations. Additionally, tourism here operates in what Rose describes as a “more controlled, boutique environment” rather than the mass-market approach that can sometimes create security vulnerabilities in other locations. This isn’t accidental—it reflects deliberate policy decisions about the type of tourism development the territory wants to encourage.

The U.S. Department of State reinforces this assessment by maintaining Anguilla at Level 1 travel advisory status—the absolute lowest risk designation possible. That simple “exercise normal precautions” guidance speaks volumes when you consider that several popular Caribbean destinations currently carry Level 2 or even Level 3 advisories due to concerns about crime, civil unrest, or inadequate healthcare infrastructure.

Context matters tremendously when evaluating safety rankings, so let’s look at where other Caribbean destinations stand. Following Anguilla in the World Population Review assessment were Barbados, St. Barts, Martinique, the Cayman Islands, and Aruba. Interestingly, other safety indices compiled in 2025, including the Caribbean Island Safety Index from Always All Inclusive, placed Aruba at the number one position, with Barbados, Grenada, and Curaçao rounding out the top spots.

These variations in rankings actually tell us something important about Caribbean safety—different methodologies emphasize different factors. The Always All Inclusive index, for instance, gave particular weight to hurricane exposure and healthcare infrastructure alongside traditional crime statistics. Aruba’s positioning outside the typical hurricane belt and its healthcare system built to Dutch standards gave it advantages in that particular assessment. Meanwhile, the World Population Review focused more heavily on crime data and political stability measures, where Anguilla’s extremely low incident rates and stable British territorial governance proved decisive.

What’s consistent across all these rankings, however, is that the same group of islands consistently appears at the top. Whether you’re looking at Anguilla, Aruba, Barbados, St. Barts, or the Cayman Islands, you’re examining destinations that have made sustained, strategic investments in tourism safety infrastructure, law enforcement capabilities, and creating secure environments for international visitors. For travel industry professionals advising clients, any of these destinations represents a low-risk option that allows you to recommend with confidence.

This safety designation isn’t merely a public relations victory for Anguilla—it carries substantial economic implications for the territory’s tourism sector, which accounts for approximately 23 percent of the island’s GDP according to recent economic data. When a destination earns recognition as the region’s safest, that designation becomes a powerful marketing differentiator in an increasingly competitive Caribbean marketplace where travelers have dozens of island options to consider.

Erin Schroeder, an Atlanta-based travel adviser and founder of Major Traveler, emphasizes this point clearly: “Safety in the Caribbean is a top three deciding factor when travelers are weighing various islands.” That statement reflects what industry data consistently shows—security concerns can make or break booking decisions, particularly among family travelers, older demographics, and first-time Caribbean visitors who may be unfamiliar with regional conditions.

The economic benefits extend beyond simply attracting more visitors. Destinations perceived as exceptionally safe can command premium pricing for accommodations and experiences, support longer average stays as travelers feel comfortable exploring independently, and generate stronger repeat visitation rates. Anguilla has already been capitalizing on these advantages—the territory’s tourism expenditure reached nearly 461 million East Caribbean dollars in 2023, reflecting the high-value, luxury-oriented approach that the island has cultivated.

There’s also a reputational multiplier effect at work. When Anguilla gets recognized by Travel + Leisure’s 2025 World’s Best Awards as one of the top islands globally—and the highest-ranked in the Caribbean—that compounds the safety messaging with broader destination appeal. The combination of security, luxury accommodations, pristine beaches, and excellent cuisine creates a comprehensive value proposition that resonates strongly with the affluent traveler segment that generates disproportionate tourism revenue.

So what does all this mean for those of us working in Caribbean tourism—whether you’re operating accommodations, managing destination marketing organizations, or advising travelers? First, Anguilla’s example demonstrates that safety excellence requires sustained, holistic commitment. This isn’t about implementing one security program or hiring more police officers. It’s about creating an entire ecosystem—from controlled development patterns to community engagement to quality tourism infrastructure—that prioritizes visitor security at every level.

Schroeder notes that beyond safety itself, travelers also seek destinations offering easy transportation and walkability, both of which Anguilla provides. She personally appreciates “the ability to walk along the beach at night to local restaurants or exercise on the island’s flat roads knowing that it’s safe to do so.” These seemingly small amenities—being able to walk to dinner after dark, going for a morning jog, letting children play freely on beaches—represent the practical manifestations of genuine safety that travelers experience on the ground.

However, it’s important for travel professionals to communicate realistic expectations about accessibility. Anguilla’s boutique appeal and controlled development come with some logistical considerations. Currently, there’s only one direct flight option from the United States. Most visitors fly into St. Maarten and take a ferry transfer, which costs approximately 115 dollars per person each way for shared service. For some clients, particularly those prioritizing convenience, this represents a meaningful access barrier. For others seeking an exclusive, off-the-beaten-path experience, that limited accessibility actually enhances the destination’s appeal by naturally limiting mass tourism.

Rose offers valuable guidance for travel professionals working with safety-conscious clients. He recommends what he calls a “layered” approach to security—one that goes beyond simply looking at official travel advisories. This includes reviewing local conditions and recent developments, checking with local hosts or destination advisers for up-to-date ground-level information, and implementing common-sense precautions like limiting displays of wealth and using registered, licensed transportation providers.

His broader point resonates throughout the industry: “Safety is dynamic, not static. The best travelers prepare by gathering accurate information before they go, monitoring while they’re there, and staying ready to respond if something changes. That’s how you travel smart, not scared.” This mindset shift—from viewing safety as a binary yes-or-no question to understanding it as an ongoing process of informed decision-making—represents best practice in contemporary travel advising.

For destinations themselves, Anguilla’s success offers a roadmap. The Anguilla Tourist Board’s messaging following the safety recognition—”Here, peace isn’t found, it’s felt”—captures something essential about how security should be experienced by visitors. It shouldn’t be heavy-handed or militarized or making travelers constantly aware of security measures. Instead, it should be woven seamlessly into the destination fabric so that travelers simply feel comfortable and at ease throughout their stay.

As we move further into 2025 and beyond, Caribbean destinations will likely face increasing pressure to demonstrate and maintain strong safety credentials. The regional tourism landscape has become more competitive, with emerging destinations throughout Latin America and even renovated European coastal areas competing for the same traveler segments. Safety excellence represents a sustainable competitive advantage—one that cannot be easily or quickly replicated and that resonates across demographic segments.

For territories like Anguilla, maintaining this position requires continued vigilance and investment. The recognition brings increased visitor numbers, which themselves can create new security challenges if not properly managed. The island’s controlled development approach and boutique tourism philosophy help mitigate these risks, but they require ongoing commitment from local government, business operators, and the community itself.

Other Caribbean destinations studying Anguilla’s success should recognize that wholesale replication isn’t necessarily feasible or even desirable. Each island has unique circumstances—different governance structures, economic resources, existing development patterns, and cultural contexts. However, the underlying principles translate across contexts: prioritize security infrastructure, manage tourism development thoughtfully rather than pursuing growth at any cost, engage local communities in tourism planning, maintain strong law enforcement capabilities, and communicate transparently about safety conditions.

The Caribbean’s overall safety landscape continues evolving, with some destinations improving their security situations while others face ongoing challenges. Travel professionals need to stay informed about these dynamic conditions rather than relying on outdated assumptions or generalizations about regional safety. Resources like the U.S. State Department’s travel advisories, regional crime statistics, industry safety assessments, and ground-level intelligence from local operators all contribute to comprehensive safety evaluation.

Anguilla’s recognition as the Caribbean’s safest destination represents more than an individual island’s success—it demonstrates what’s possible when destinations make deliberate, sustained commitments to visitor security and controlled tourism development. For an industry still rebuilding from pandemic disruptions and navigating evolving traveler priorities, these examples of excellence matter tremendously.

The practical takeaway for Caribbean tourism professionals is straightforward: safety credentials increasingly function as prerequisites rather than differentiators. Travelers, particularly those from major source markets in North America and Europe, now expect robust security as a baseline requirement. Destinations that can go beyond meeting expectations to actually excelling in safety—as Anguilla has done—position themselves advantageously for capturing premium traveler segments and commanding higher tourism revenues.

As Rose reminds us, traveling intelligently means traveling informed rather than fearful. For those of us working throughout the Caribbean tourism ecosystem, our responsibility involves providing accurate, current information that allows travelers to make confident decisions about their adventures. Anguilla’s achievement shows what’s possible when everyone—from government officials to resort operators to local communities—pulls together toward creating genuinely secure, welcoming environments where international visitors can relax and enjoy everything this remarkable region offers.

More Travel News