A Taste of Jamaica Grows in Syracuse: Erma’s Island Plans Major Downtown Expansion

There’s something magical happening in downtown Syracuse, and it smells like jerk chicken, curry goat, and freshly made coco bread. Erma’s Island, the beloved Jamaican food stand that’s been serving authentic Caribbean flavors at Salt City Market since 2021, is about to get a whole lot bigger. The restaurant is planning a full-service expansion that promises to bring even more of Jamaica’s vibrant culinary traditions to upstate New York.

For anyone who’s tasted Latoya’s cooking at the current Salt City Market location on South Salina Street, this news feels like finding out your favorite vacation spot is opening a resort next door. The expansion represents more than just additional square footage—it’s a celebration of how Caribbean cuisine has captured the hearts (and stomachs) of Syracuse residents who might never have experienced these bold, sun-drenched flavors before.

Walking into Salt City Market for the first time can feel overwhelming in the best possible way. The 78,000-square-foot space buzzes with energy, housing vendors from Burma to Baghdad, Thailand to the Caribbean. But there’s something special about the line that forms at Erma’s Island, where the aroma of allspice, scotch bonnet peppers, and slow-cooked meats draws curious diners and homesick Jamaicans alike.

Latoya migrated from Jamaica at nineteen with a dream as bold as her grandmother’s jerk seasoning. Opening a restaurant featuring outstanding Jamaican cuisine had been a lifelong vision—one planted by Mama Erma, her maternal grandmother who taught her the sacred art of Caribbean cooking starting at age eight. Watching her celebrated grandfather entice generations of food lovers in Jamaica, then learning from her mother’s skilled hands, Latoya absorbed more than recipes. She inherited a legacy of flavor, family, and the kind of hospitality that makes strangers feel like longtime friends.

Since Salt City Market opened its doors in January 2021, Erma’s Island has become one of the food hall’s standout success stories. The market itself represents a beautiful experiment in urban revitalization—transforming a previously run-down area into a vibrant destination complete with mixed-income housing above, a cooperative grocery store, and that excellent coffee bar where you can grab an espresso martini while deciding between Vietnamese pho or Middle Eastern shawarma.

If you’ve been paying attention to food trends, you’ve noticed Caribbean flavors popping up everywhere from food trucks to fine dining establishments. There’s a reason the National Restaurant Association identified Caribbean food as a top trend to watch, and why Jamaican cuisine now receives as many monthly Google searches as healthy food options—approximately 201,000 searches per month.

Caribbean cooking represents something Americans increasingly crave: bold, unapologetic flavor combined with comfort and soul. After decades of being relegated to mom-and-pop shops in immigrant neighborhoods, Caribbean cuisine is finally getting its moment in the spotlight. Chefs across the country are elevating traditional dishes, introducing techniques that respect heritage while appealing to contemporary palates.

The cuisine’s growing popularity stems from several factors. First, there’s the spice profile—that intoxicating blend of allspice, ginger, scotch bonnet peppers, and warming spices that creates layers of flavor impossible to forget after your first bite. Second, Caribbean food emphasizes affordable proteins like chicken, goat, and oxtail, slow-cooked until tender and infused with complex seasonings. Third, there’s an inherent healthfulness to many Caribbean dishes, featuring fresh vegetables, rice and beans, and cooking methods that prioritize flavor over heavy sauces.

But perhaps most importantly, Caribbean cuisine tells stories. Every plate carries history—the fusion of African, Indigenous, European, Indian, and Chinese influences that created something entirely new on tropical islands. When you eat jerk chicken, you’re tasting centuries of migration, adaptation, and cultural exchange. That’s powerful stuff, especially in our increasingly globalized world where people seek authentic connections through food.

Anyone who’s visited Erma’s Island knows that authenticity isn’t just a buzzword here—it’s a promise kept with every order. The current menu showcases classics that transport diners straight to Kingston’s bustling streets or quiet countryside kitchens where grandmothers still cook over traditional wood fires.

Take the jerk chicken, for instance. This isn’t the watered-down version you might find at chain restaurants. The chicken arrives tender and juicy, bathed in a sauce that delivers heat, sweetness, and that unmistakable pimento wood smokiness. Served alongside rice and peas (which, confusingly for newcomers, actually means rice cooked with red kidney beans in coconut milk), the dish represents comfort food at its finest.

Then there’s the curry chicken—mild, sweet, and full of flavor that builds rather than overwhelms. Many first-timers start here, discovering that Jamaican curry differs significantly from its Indian cousin. It’s less about intense heat and more about creating a harmonious blend where coconut, turmeric, and curry powder merge with tender chicken in a sauce you’ll want to soak up with every available carb on your plate.

For the adventurous, oxtail with butter beans offers rich, falling-apart meat in a deeply savory gravy that makes you understand why this dish commands premium prices despite its humble origins. The rasta pasta—a fusion creation that’s become a Caribbean-American classic—tosses jerk-spiced chicken with colorful peppers in a creamy sauce over pasta, bridging Caribbean tradition with Italian-American comfort food in a way that just works.

Don’t overlook the sides and accompaniments that complete the experience. Fried plantains provide sweet, caramelized contrast to savory mains. Coco bread—soft, slightly sweet, and brushed with coconut—serves as the perfect vehicle for Jamaican patties or simply eaten on its own. And those Jamaican patties themselves, with flaky golden crusts encasing spiced beef seasoned with scotch bonnet and black pepper, represent portable sunshine you can eat with your hands.

The expansion from food stand to full-service restaurant represents a significant evolution not just for Erma’s Island, but for Syracuse’s entire culinary landscape. While the current Salt City Market setup works beautifully for quick lunches and casual dinners, a dedicated restaurant space opens up entirely new possibilities.

Imagine settling into a comfortable seat with actual table service, a full bar featuring rum cocktails that showcase Caribbean spirits, and a menu that can expand beyond the current offerings to include appetizers, desserts, and daily specials. Picture weekend brunch featuring banana bread French toast or ackee and saltfish—Jamaica’s national dish of salted cod sautéed with the unique ackee fruit, onions, tomatoes, and scotch bonnet peppers.

A full-service location also means the opportunity for larger gatherings, private events, and the kind of dining experience where you linger over multiple courses, trying dishes you might skip when grabbing takeout. It means space for the restaurant to truly showcase Caribbean hospitality—that warm, welcoming approach where servers feel like extended family sharing their favorite recipes with you.

For Syracuse, a city that’s actively working to diversify its restaurant scene and support minority-owned businesses, this expansion represents exactly the kind of success story that encourages other entrepreneurs. Salt City Market was specifically designed as an incubator for food businesses, providing affordable entry points for vendors who might not otherwise have the resources to open standalone restaurants. Seeing one of those vendors grow enough to warrant a full-service location validates the entire model.

Erma’s Island’s success story fits into a larger narrative about Caribbean cuisine finally receiving the recognition it deserves across America. For decades, Caribbean food thrived quietly in neighborhoods with recent immigrants—Crown Heights in Brooklyn, Little Havana in Miami, Humboldt Park in Chicago—but remained largely unknown to mainstream diners.

That’s changing rapidly. Chefs with Caribbean heritage are opening restaurants that range from fast-casual to fine dining, refusing to accept that their cuisine belongs only in takeout containers. They’re using premium ingredients, innovative techniques, and beautiful presentations while staying true to traditional flavors that define the region.

Roy Choi, the chef who revolutionized food trucks and popularized Korean cuisine in America, runs Sunny Spot in Venice, California, where he riffs on Puerto Rican mofongo and Jamaican oxtails. In New Orleans, St. Lucia-born Nina Compton serves elevated Caribbean fare at Compere Lapin, where curried goat ranks among the most popular dishes. Brooklyn’s Gladys, run by chef Junior Felix from St. Lucia, applies traditional smoking techniques to island-style barbecue that’s drawing crowds far beyond the Caribbean diaspora.

These chefs understand something crucial: you can honor tradition while evolving it. You can serve food that makes grandmothers nod in approval while also surprising diners who thought they knew Caribbean cuisine. You can charge fine-dining prices when you’re delivering fine-dining experiences—beautiful presentations, knowledgeable service, carefully curated wine lists that complement bold flavors.

Syracuse might not seem like an obvious location for Caribbean food to flourish, but look closer and the pieces fit together perfectly. The city has a growing diversity, with immigrant communities from around the world enriching the cultural fabric. The presence of Syracuse University brings students and faculty from Caribbean nations who crave tastes of home.

Moreover, Syracuse’s food scene has shown increasing sophistication and adventurousness. Diners here support restaurants serving Burmese, Ethiopian, Vietnamese, and Middle Eastern cuisines—all thriving within Salt City Market and beyond. There’s clearly an appetite for authentic international flavors prepared by people who know these cuisines intimately.

The city’s affordable real estate compared to coastal metros makes it feasible for restaurants to expand without astronomical overhead crushing their margins. Community support for local businesses runs strong, with organizations actively working to promote minority entrepreneurship and downtown revitalization. Salt City Market itself, developed by the non-profit Syracuse Urban Partnership with support from the Allyn Family Foundation and JPMorgan Chase, demonstrates the kind of public-private collaboration that helps food businesses succeed.

Winter in Syracuse—let’s be honest—is brutal. But that creates perfect conditions for the kind of warming, soul-satisfying comfort food that Caribbean cuisine delivers so beautifully. When snow piles up outside and wind whips off Lake Ontario, a plate of curry goat or brown stew chicken with rice and peas provides the kind of sustenance that goes beyond mere calories. It’s edible sunshine, a reminder that somewhere, palm trees sway and ocean breezes blow warm.

While specific details about the new full-service location remain under development, we can make educated guesses based on successful Caribbean restaurant expansions elsewhere and the foundation Erma’s Island has already built.

The expanded menu will likely feature everything currently available at the Salt City Market stand, plus additional offerings that shine in a full-service setting. Appetizers might include saltfish fritters, jerk wings with house-made hot sauce, or festival (sweet fried dumplings that are slightly crispy outside and soft within). Soups could showcase the hearty, coconut-based seafood stews that are Caribbean comfort food at its finest.

Main courses will almost certainly expand beyond current offerings to include dishes like escovitch fish (fried whole fish topped with spicy pickled vegetables), brown stew chicken (a Sunday dinner classic), or vegetarian options showcasing the cuisine’s plant-based traditions—because contrary to popular belief, Caribbean cooking offers plenty of delicious meat-free dishes.

The beverage program presents exciting possibilities. Imagine house-made ginger beer, sorrel (a tart, refreshing drink made from hibiscus flowers), or rum punch that actually tastes like the Caribbean rather than sugary juice. A full bar could feature aged rums from Jamaica, Barbados, and Trinidad, showcased in classic cocktails or innovative creations that incorporate tropical fruits and spices.

Dessert might bring rum cake, sweet potato pudding, or coconut drops—simple preparations that let quality ingredients shine. And hopefully, there will be plenty of that banana bread that current customers rave about, possibly transformed into French toast or bread pudding for brunch service.

What makes the expansion particularly meaningful is how it represents immigrant entrepreneurship at its finest. Latoya came to America with dreams and determination, working toward a goal that honors her grandmother’s legacy while creating something new. Her success creates jobs, adds to Syracuse’s tax base, introduces residents to a rich culinary tradition, and serves as inspiration for other entrepreneurs with their own food dreams.

This is how food scenes evolve and improve—not through chains expanding into new markets, but through passionate individuals bringing authentic flavors from their homelands and sharing them with new communities. Every time Syracuse residents choose to eat at Erma’s Island, they’re voting with their dollars for more diverse, interesting, locally-owned food options.

The restaurant also serves an important role for Caribbean immigrants and their descendants in the Syracuse area. Having access to authentic food from home matters deeply when you’re far from your birthplace. It’s not just about feeding your body but nourishing your soul, maintaining connections to culture and memory through familiar flavors prepared the way your mother or grandmother made them.

As Erma’s Island prepares for its expansion, Syracuse stands at a delicious crossroads. The success of this beloved Jamaican restaurant signals growing sophistication in the local food scene and increasing appreciation for authentic international cuisines. It demonstrates that quality food, served with heart and hospitality, can thrive anywhere—not just in major coastal cities.

For food lovers in Syracuse, this expansion means more opportunities to experience the vibrant flavors of Caribbean cooking in a setting that does justice to the cuisine’s complexity and cultural significance. For Latoya and her team, it represents a dream fulfilled and new chapters waiting to be written.

Whether you’re a longtime fan counting the days until the new location opens, or someone who’s never tried Caribbean food before, the expansion of Erma’s Island offers something special: a chance to taste history, culture, and love on a plate, prepared by someone who learned these recipes at her grandmother’s side and brought them halfway across the world to share with anyone willing to try something beautifully, boldly different.

The next time you’re downtown Syracuse and smell those unmistakable aromas of allspice and scotch bonnet peppers drifting on the air, follow your nose. Your taste buds will thank you for discovering—or rediscovering—why Caribbean cuisine is finally getting the recognition it has always deserved.

More Food & Wine News