How Modern Travelers Are Gaming Loyalty Programs: Industry Research Reveals Strategic Reward Optimization

The travel loyalty landscape has fundamentally transformed from simple point collection into a sophisticated rewards economy where strategic optimization has become the norm. Recent research from Phocuswright reveals a striking statistic: 84% of leisure travelers engaged in at least one loyalty program gaming behavior within the past year, demonstrating that reward optimization is no longer a niche activity but mainstream travel planning strategy.

Understanding Loyalty Program Gaming Behaviors

Gaming loyalty programs involves strategic actions travelers take to maximize points, miles, and elite status benefits beyond typical earning patterns. This phenomenon reflects how travelers have become sophisticated participants in what has evolved into a complex rewards sub-economy.

The research identifies several common gaming behaviors that have become normalized among travelers. One in five airline loyalty program users admitted to flying somewhere they would not have otherwise chosen simply to maintain their elite status. Similarly, one in four active hotel program members stayed at properties they wouldn’t have selected if not for status preservation considerations.

More aggressive optimization strategies are surprisingly common. Thirty-nine percent of travelers have charged gift cards to their credit cards with the intention of using those gift cards themselves while earning points through the transaction. Twenty-seven percent opened credit cards specifically planning to reduce spending or close the account after receiving welcome bonuses. Sixteen percent manufactured spending by purchasing items on behalf of others to accumulate rewards.

The Gap Between Engagement and True Brand Loyalty

While participation rates in loyalty programs remain impressively high, this engagement doesn’t necessarily translate into consistent brand usage. Across airlines, hotels, and online travel agencies, between 57% and 68% of travelers who identified one or more preferred brands still booked with alternative brands during the past year.

“When we talk about loyalty in travel, the conversation often gets reduced to points and miles, but that misses the bigger picture,” explained Madeline List, Manager of Research and Special Projects at Phocuswright. “Travelers are highly engaged with these programs and they are gaming them in very intentional ways, yet engagement alone does not equal loyalty.”

This pattern persists even among travelers with elite status or those who describe their brand usage as highly consistent. When competitors offer better pricing, more convenient schedules, or superior availability, travelers frequently defect from their preferred brands.

What Actually Drives Brand Preference

Phocuswright’s comprehensive analysis demonstrates that loyalty programs reinforce customer preference but rarely initiate it. Value for money, perceived pricing fairness, reliability, and ease of use consistently outrank loyalty programs as primary drivers of brand preference across all travel sectors.

The research series “Playing Favorites: What Makes a Go-To Brand in Travel, and Why Do Customers Stray?” reveals that while points and perks can amplify existing affinity, they cannot compensate for fundamental gaps in service execution or competitive pricing.

True loyalty emerges from the totality of brand interactions over a customer’s lifetime. Points and perks strengthen that relationship, but without strong product quality, fair pricing, and experiences that consistently deliver, loyalty programs alone cannot meaningfully influence behavior.

Economic Pressures Reshape Redemption Patterns

Amid tightening budgets and economic uncertainty, travelers increasingly view points and miles redemptions as essential tools for making travel more affordable, frequent, and comfortable. Approximately 52% of travelers paid for at least one portion of their recent trip using loyalty redemptions.

Half of travelers who redeemed points or miles on recent leisure trips were visiting destinations for the first time, highlighting the importance of flexible redemption options that extend beyond familiar markets. This pattern suggests travelers are using rewards strategically to explore new destinations they might not have afforded otherwise.

Generational Differences in Loyalty Approach

Younger travelers demonstrate distinctly different attitudes toward brand consistency compared to older generations. Roughly half of Generation Z and Millennial travelers indicate that variety matters more than consistently using the same brands.

For these demographics, trying new brands and experiences isn’t a sign of dissatisfaction but rather an intentional component of the travel experience itself. Millennials particularly lead in using rewards-focused methods to stretch travel budgets, with 94% strategically employing techniques to earn additional points compared to other generations.

Generation X and Millennials show the highest loyalty program enrollment at 85%, followed by Baby Boomers at 80% and Generation Z at 75%. This suggests continued enrollment growth as younger generations gain more travel experience and disposable income.

The Rise of the Rewards Sub-Economy

Loyalty programs have evolved far beyond their original purpose of encouraging consistent brand usage. Today’s rewards landscape represents a full sub-economy involving complex deals between providers, intermediaries, and financial institutions.

This transformation has spawned specialty publications dedicated to maximizing rewards and created an enthusiastic community of “hackers” focused on extracting maximum value from points and miles. The sophistication of these strategies reflects how normalized optimization has become.

Travel brands must recognize that their loyalty programs operate within this broader ecosystem where travelers routinely compare earning rates, redemption values, and benefits across multiple programs simultaneously.

Implications for Travel Brands

For travel companies, these findings present both challenges and opportunities. Loyalty programs remain deeply embedded in how travelers plan, book, and experience travel, but heavy participation doesn’t guarantee consistent brand usage.

Programs must deliver value from a comprehensive perspective where product quality, pricing strategy, and rewards work in conjunction to secure genuine customer loyalty. Airlines, hotels, and online travel agencies that understand this dynamic can leverage loyalty programs as reinforcement rather than relying on them as the primary retention tool.

Barclays research corroborates these trends, finding that 79% of travelers depend on loyalty programs, with 82% acknowledging they would travel differently or not at all without travel rewards. This dependency underscores both the opportunity and responsibility brands face in meeting evolving traveler expectations.

The Future of Travel Loyalty Programs

Looking ahead to 2025 and beyond, successful loyalty programs will increasingly focus on personalization, flexibility, and experiential rewards that resonate with diverse traveler segments. The experiential travel market is projected to exceed $3.1 trillion, with 74% of travelers viewing experiences as having moderate to massive impact on trip planning.

Programs like Marriott Bonvoy’s Moments initiative exemplify this shift by offering diverse experiential options including VIP event access and unique activity combinations that extend beyond standard travel rewards.

Sustainability is emerging as another critical factor, particularly for younger generations making travel decisions based on environmental impact. Loyalty programs that incorporate carbon offset credits, eco-hotel partnerships, and sustainable travel options will better align with evolving consumer values.

Strategic Takeaways for Travelers and Brands

For travelers, the data confirms that strategic optimization of loyalty programs has become mainstream. Understanding gaming techniques and maximizing rewards is now an expected part of travel planning rather than an exceptional behavior.

For brands, the message is clear: loyalty programs are valuable retention tools when combined with excellent service, competitive pricing, and reliable experiences. Programs alone cannot overcome fundamental shortcomings in product delivery or value proposition.

The future belongs to travel companies that recognize loyalty as an outcome rather than an input—the natural result of consistently delivering value, reliability, and experiences that genuinely meet traveler needs across the complete customer journey.

More Travel News